Digital SAT Reading and Writing · Information and Ideas
SAT Command of Evidence Practice Questions
Command of Evidence questions ask you to pick the quotation or data point that best supports or illustrates a claim. There are two types: textual (quotations from a work) and quantitative (tables and graphs).
Updated . Questions are original BlitzSAT items written to the College Board's published skill specifications. They are not official SAT questions.
How Command of Evidence questions appear on the SAT
Textual: a claim about a literary work or a researcher's hypothesis, plus four quotations or findings. Quantitative: a short passage plus a table or graph, and a question asking which choice uses the data to complete or support a statement.
Command of Evidence is part of the Information and Ideas domain, which makes up about 26% of the Reading and Writing section (12–14 questions per test).
How to approach Command of Evidence questions
1Restate the exact claim to be supported, including every part of it. A claim with two parts needs evidence for both.
2For quantitative questions, read the axis labels, units, and categories before reading the choices.
3Check each choice against the data. Many wrong choices state true numbers that do not support the claim.
4For hypotheses, choose the finding that would make the hypothesis more likely, not one that is merely related.
Common mistakes
Choosing an accurate reading of the graph that does not address the claim.
Supporting only half of a two-part claim.
Picking a quotation on the same topic that does not illustrate the specific trait named in the claim.
10 SAT Command of Evidence practice questions with answers
Pick an answer to check it. Each explanation covers the correct answer and why each of the other choices is wrong. The set runs from easy to hard.
0 / 10 answered
1EasyTextual: support a character interpretation in an original vignette
Changing an answer need not indicate carelessness; it can demonstrate responsiveness to evidence. Consider Mara, a participant in a hypothetical language study. Mara arrived early and arranged her instruction cards in a neat row. After hearing two phrases in an invented language, she confidently predicted the rule for forming a question. The next recording contradicted her prediction. Mara crossed out her original rule and wrote a new one that accounted for all three examples. She then waited for the next recording.
Which quotation best supports the interpretation that Mara is willing to revise her thinking in response to evidence?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D
Choice D shows Mara replacing her original rule with one that fits the new evidence as well as the earlier examples. This action directly demonstrates a willingness to revise her thinking.Why the other choices are wrongAArriving early and organizing materials suggest preparation, not revision of an idea in response to evidence.BMaking a confident initial prediction shows Mara forming an idea, but not her willingness to change it.CThis sentence establishes that contradictory evidence appeared, but it does not describe how Mara responded.
2EasyTextual: support a hypothesis with a discriminating observation
Before starting work on the wooden birdhouse, Nico pulled an extra stool beside his workbench. There was already plenty of room on the bench for his supplies. His aunt suspected that he hoped his young cousin would join him, rather than that he needed somewhere to stack the wood.
Which additional detail would most strongly support the aunt's suspicion?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B
A child-sized apron and spare tools prepare a place for a young helper. This detail directly supports the aunt's suspicion that Nico wants his cousin to join him, rather than simply wanting storage space.Why the other choices are wrongAPutting wood on the stool supports the alternative explanation that Nico needs a place to stack supplies.CChecking the stool's height does not specifically indicate that Nico expects his cousin; it could also help him arrange materials.DImproving the lighting at Nico's own seat does not explain why he brought over an extra stool.
3EasyQuantitative: compare trends across groups in a text table
Ivo had given every character in his play a favorite phrase, hoping to make their voices distinct. In a hypothetical workshop, two groups of 20 readers each read the earlier draft and then the revision. After each reading, they reported whether they had trouble identifying speakers. Ivo concluded that reported confusion decreased in both groups, with a larger decrease among beginning readers.
Reader group
Readers reporting confusion: earlier draft
Readers reporting confusion: revision
Beginning
12
5
Experienced
8
6
Which statement best uses the table to support Ivo's conclusion?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A
Beginning readers' reports fell from 12 to 5, a decrease of 7. Experienced readers' reports fell from 8 to 6, a decrease of 2. Both groups therefore reported less confusion, and the beginning group had the larger decrease.Why the other choices are wrongBBeginning readers reported more confusion with the earlier draft: 12 readers compared with 8 experienced readers.CThe values 5 and 6 are the revision's counts, not the decreases. The actual decreases are 7 and 2.DExperienced readers' reports decreased from 8 to 6; they did not increase.
4MediumQuantitative: qualify a generalization using a counterexample in a text table
Suppose I kept the following hypothetical revision journal. Each session began with a walk, followed by thirty minutes of editing. I used sentences revised as a measure of productivity and fewer unresolved margin comments as a measure of completeness. Looking at these entries, I might be tempted to claim that every session following a walk longer than ten minutes outperformed the ten-minute-walk session on both measures.
Walk duration (minutes)
Sentences revised
Unresolved comments
10
12
5
15
16
3
20
10
2
Which choice best uses the table to identify a limitation of the narrator's claim?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C
The claim requires every session after a longer walk to outperform the ten-minute-walk session on both measures. After the twenty-minute walk, completeness was better by the narrator's measure—2 unresolved comments instead of 5—but productivity was lower, with 10 sentences revised instead of 12. That session is therefore a counterexample.Why the other choices are wrongAThe fifteen-minute-walk session improved on both measures relative to the ten-minute-walk session, so this comparison supports rather than limits the claim.BThe comment counts show improvement in completeness. They do not reveal the failure to improve productivity that limits the claim.DThe claim compares each longer-walk session with the ten-minute-walk session; it does not require the longest walk to produce the most revisions. This choice does not establish that the twenty-minute-walk session fell below the ten-minute baseline.
5MediumTextual: weaken an explanation with a relevant finding
In a hypothetical investigation of wetland management, researchers observe that reed harvesting declines after volunteers begin speaking with harvesters about protecting reed habitats. The researchers propose that these conversations strengthened the harvesters' commitment to conservation, rather than merely discouraging them from cutting reeds where volunteers could see them.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the researchers' proposed explanation?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D
The researchers distinguish a stronger commitment to conservation from avoidance of being observed. Moving an equivalent amount of harvesting to an unmonitored wetland suggests that the harvesters changed where they cut reeds, not their commitment to protecting reed habitats. This weakens the proposed explanation without conclusively establishing their motives.Why the other choices are wrongARemembering the volunteers' explanations shows that the information reached the harvesters. It does not contradict the possibility that their commitment to conservation increased.BA decline despite normally increasing demand is consistent with the intervention influencing behavior, but it does not distinguish conservation motives from avoidance of observation.CAsking about less damaging harvesting methods is consistent with concern for conservation and therefore does not weaken the proposed explanation.
6MediumQuantitative: evaluate a predicted ordering using a text table
In a hypothetical materials study, a team tests three coatings on identical flexible panels. Before testing, the team predicts that coating R will withstand the most bending cycles before cracking, coating S the next most, and coating T the fewest. The table presents the results under two temperature conditions.
Temperature condition
R: cycles before cracking
S: cycles before cracking
T: cycles before cracking
Cool
84
71
63
Warm
58
66
49
Which statement best evaluates the team's prediction using the table?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C
The prediction is R, then S, then T. The cool-condition results follow that order: 84, 71, and 63 cycles. Under the warm condition, S withstands 66 cycles and R withstands 58, while T remains last at 49. Thus, only R and S reverse their predicted positions.Why the other choices are wrongAT being last satisfies only part of the prediction. Under the warm condition, S outperforms R, contrary to the predicted ordering.BS outperforming R contradicts the prediction rather than confirming it. The complete predicted ordering holds under the cool condition.DS remains ahead of T under both conditions. The reversal under the warm condition involves R and S.
7MediumTextual: connect a proposed mechanism to an observation
In a hypothetical materials study, researchers find fewer bubbles in a coating applied to warmed porous tiles than in the same coating applied to unheated tiles. They propose that warming allows air trapped inside the tiles to escape through connected pores before the coating hardens. Under this explanation, fewer bubbles result from air leaving the tiles, not merely from heat changing the coating’s hardening rate.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the proposed mechanism?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D
The proposed mechanism depends on air escaping through pores. Choice D shows that preventing this escape removes the benefit of warming even though the hardening rate remains unchanged. This specifically connects the bubble reduction to the proposed air-release pathway.Why the other choices are wrongAA change in hardening rate concerns the alternative explanation mentioned in the passage, not evidence that trapped air escapes.BSimilar pores establish comparable tile structure but do not show that warming causes air to leave through those pores.CThis finding extends the observed bubble reduction to other coating thicknesses but does not distinguish air escape from other effects of warming.
8HardTextual: select evidence that distinguishes competing explanations
In a hypothetical humanities project, curators revise a print exhibition in two ways: they replace chronological placement with groups based on recurring motifs, and they add labels identifying those motifs. Visitors subsequently make more comparisons between prints sharing a motif. One curator argues that the labels supply interpretive categories that prompt comparison. Another argues that the labels are incidental: comparisons increase simply because related prints are now closer together. The team plans follow-up displays to determine which change accounts for the increase.
Which finding from otherwise comparable follow-up displays would most strongly support the first curator's explanation over the second's?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B
B separates the two changes. An increase with motif labels but unchanged chronological placement supports the proposed role of interpretive categories. The absence of an increase with regrouping alone argues against proximity as the explanation. Together, these findings favor the first curator's account.Why the other choices are wrongAChanging labels and placement together preserves the original confounding: either explanation could account for the increase.CA consistent difference associated with visitors' prior knowledge does not distinguish the effects of labels from those of placement.DThis pattern favors the second curator: regrouping works without motif labels, while labels alone do not increase comparisons.
9HardQuantitative: combine a stated claim with a percentage text table
In a hypothetical ecology investigation, researchers track patches occupied by a plant species at sites connected by habitat corridors and at isolated sites. In the table, Initial and Final are percentages of all patches in each group. Establishment is the percentage of initially empty patches that became occupied during the investigation. A researcher argues that final occupancy alone can obscure stronger establishment in previously empty patches.
Site group
Initial (%)
Establishment (%)
Final (%)
Connected
20
50
58
Isolated
80
25
65
Which comparison most accurately supports the researcher's argument, accounting for the different bases of the percentages?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C
Choice C correctly distinguishes the percentage bases. At connected sites, 80% of patches were initially empty, and 50% of those became occupied, so newly occupied patches represented 0.80×0.50=0.40, or 40%, of all patches. At isolated sites, the corresponding share was 0.20×0.25=0.05, or 5%. Nevertheless, final occupancy was lower at connected sites: 58% versus 65%. Thus, final occupancy alone obscures the stronger establishment shown at connected sites.Why the other choices are wrongAThe newly occupied shares are calculated correctly, but the final comparison is reversed: connected sites had 58% final occupancy, below the isolated sites' 65%.BThe values 10% and 20% result from applying establishment rates to initially occupied patches. Establishment rates apply to initially empty patches instead.DThe values 50% and 25% describe shares of initially empty patches, not shares of all patches. This choice ignores the different starting occupancy percentages.
10HardQuantitative: support a claim using two rows of a text table
Leda’s story ends with a courier returning an unopened letter. She wants readers to understand the action without settling on one explanation for it. In a hypothetical reader study, separate groups assess draft-and-revision pairs. Confusion is measured by the percentage misidentifying the action; interpretive openness, by the percentage finding multiple motives plausible. Effectiveness at reducing confusion is measured as the percentage-point decrease in errors. Leda argues that revisions can be equally effective by this measure yet differ sharply in how much interpretive openness they preserve.
Revision
Action errors, draft → revision (%)
Multiple motives plausible, draft → revision (%)
Reorder spatial details
60 → 30
70 → 68
Add motive explanation
40 → 10
68 → 36
Add chronology note
50 → 25
72 → 70
Which comparison of two rows most directly supports Leda’s argument?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A
Choice A uses the passage’s specified measure: percentage-point decrease, not final error rate or proportional decrease. Spatial reordering reduced errors from 60 to 30 percent, and the motive explanation reduced them from 40 to 10 percent—30 points each. Yet multiple-motive responses decreased by only 2 points with spatial reordering and by 32 points with the motive explanation. Thus, equal reductions in confusion accompanied sharply different preservation of interpretive openness.Why the other choices are wrongBHalving is a proportional comparison, not the specified percentage-point measure: these error decreases were 30 and 25 points. Moreover, both revisions produced the same 2-point decrease in openness, not sharply different effects.CThe final percentages show differences but do not establish equal effectiveness. The motive explanation reduced errors by 30 points, whereas the chronology note reduced them by 25 points.DDifferent final error rates do not imply unequal reductions from different starting rates. Both revisions reduced errors by 30 percentage points, so the statement misinterprets the comparison.
These are 10 of 208 questions on this skill in the BlitzSAT question bank.
Practice the rest by difficulty, timed or untimed, with your history saved. Free, no credit card.